narrow minded? Why Bayern Munich’s attack avoids the show

When Bayern Munich Smashing five goals against RB Leipzig in the DFL-Supercup Cup to open the 2022/23 season, one might have been forgiven for thinking no defense in the world has any chance of containing Germany. Standard Champion. Indeed, European champions Eintracht Frankfurt lost 6-1, but since then more modest outputs have been the norm, with teams from Union Berlin to VFB Stuttgart pressing on spaces and snatching points from the Bavarians. Was Julian Nagelsmann’s narrow offensive scheme discovered?

First, let’s define what we mean by “tight” – because the composition itself was not always so. The Bayern Munich 4-2-2-2 featured a variety of shapes on the front four, both with double scores and traditional wings. However, the ultimate pattern of opportunity generation remains consistently tight, as a fine imagination from Tifo Separation From Bayern – Barcelona Champions League The game revealed last week:

Even when Bayern get into threatening positions on a large scale, players tend to dribble or pass things inside.
Football Tifo

Bayern Nagelsmann doesn’t often create from wide positions, and even in a match like Barcelona’s – where Bayern used Sadio Mane and Leroy Sane on the wings – the selection looks more interactive and defensive. In this case, Barcelona an act Creation of wide, with prominent wings in Ousmane Dembele and Rafinha; I doubled Bayern’s extra speed on the wings and managed to build a more effective 4-4-2 in defence.

Without Robert Lewandowski in Bavarian red, it might simply make no sense to send spam crossbreed messages. On the other hand, Sadio Mane and Thomas Muller have aerial threat capabilities and it might make sense to separate defense, right? However, even when Bayern achieved greater distances in the Barcelona lines, they still attacked in the middle of the field. Hansi Flick never will.

Reinforcement of Leroy Sane’s goal against Barcelona. Bayern’s forwards are directed in the middle. Thomas Muller’s wide movement (AM) is just to pull the center back. | CBS / Paramount +

why? It comes down to Julian Nagelsmann’s focus on risk aversion and defensive structure. He’s not a defensive-minded coach – quite the contrary. But broad attack patterns are a double-edged sword. The attacking team is as weakly spread as the defensive team. In a Nagelsmann 4-2-2-2 game, if the ball is lost centrally in the final third, the counter press can immediately put pressure on with the front four punching the opponent.

In contrast, if the ball is lost wide, Bayern’s high streak is immediately put in a more dangerous position – and the opponent has more time and space to play through Bayern’s pressure and, in fact, the midfield.

To be fair, that didn’t always preclude goals. Bayern did not always record their potential in this system. However, Julian Nagelsmann appears to have made the trade-off. The current gathering of attacking speed and flair in Bayern Munich could Play the style further by adding another dimension – width – to their arsenal, but in balance, sacrificing site integrity and a counter-pressure structure isn’t worth it.

If it helps the team enjoy some 2-0 rather than 5-3, Bayern fans will have no complaints.